Location is a big draw at Beachview Cottages, which sits a few hundred feet from white sand in the middle of a small island, a short drive from the stores on Tarpon Bay Road. The 40-year-old property retains bare-foot appeal through its collection of 22 airy, standalone bungalows with wood laminate floors, white wicker furniture, and small kitchenettes. Most visitors have noted that rooms offer a simple stay and that the decor here, even in refurbished rooms, is unabashedly ‘80s. A few have also complained that the property’s pet-friendly policy results in occasional unwanted noise.

This rustic, mid-range property, set on a narrow strip of land between Sanibel and Captiva islands and on an active marina, consists of simple, standalone cottages. Some of the full kitchenettes are set directly next to Sanibel Captiva Road, which guests have noted can generate steady, if not terrible, traffic. The property has been in existence for decades and many families are return visitors. Some guests have noted that while bungalows are well-kept, there may be small issues related to wear and tear -- doors loose on hinges, rusty areas in the shower -- and more significant ones like temperamental air-conditioning units.