In the tiny village of Pomonte, on Elba's west end, this two-and-a-half-pearl hotel offers 23 tidy rooms just across the street from the sea. While rooms are nothing fancy, flat-screen TVs and air-conditioning make them a decent value; some are more modern, though others are dated. There's a lovely little restaurant and terrace -- meal times can be strict, though the food is delicious and homemade -- and standard rates include freebies like a continental breakfast, Wi-Fi, and bike rentals. Situated just across the street from a pebble beach, the property stays quiet and the center of town is just up the road. Those looking for similarly simple digs near a sandy beach should consider Le Acacie Hotel & Residence, though it's at Elba's east end and is pricier.

Hotel Belmare is a small, family-run hotel in Patresi, a tiny hamlet of Marciana on the western coast of Elba Island -- probably the wildest and most rugged part of the isle. The hotel is what Italians would call a “pensione” -- a boarding house -- and both full- and half-board rates are offered. Much of the success of this hotel is due to the owner, who receives guests, helps them with luggage, suggests beaches or trekking itineraries, and serves them in the restaurant. Rooms are very clean and simple -- almost monastic -- but noisy and with no air-conditioning or fans. There are very few on-site amenities.